Will the Fed blink?
- USD/ZAR
- 17.50
- EUR/ZAR
- 19.22
- GBP/ZAR
- 22.94
- Brent crude
- $92.51
- Gold
- $3,561.38
Key indicators. All information is at the time of writing.
The United States (US) Federal Reserve (Fed) is preparing to raise rates, despite a soft equity market. This move is rarer than investors may appreciate, as they have spent the past decade and a half relying on the central bank to cushion equity market declines. Analysis published by InvestmentNews found that of the 76 rate increases the Fed made between 1980 and 2018, only two came at a time when the S&P 500 was experiencing a sustained downward trend.
This year, however, on 17 November, the S&P 500 closed at its lowest level since July, while the October Consumer Price Index (CPI) print has left markets pricing in a hike at the 8 to 9 December Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) meeting, making this an unusual point in the equity cycle for the Fed to be raising rates, and one worth considering in the context of what has come before.
A brief history
As we know, history is not always a perfect guide to what comes next in financial markets, particularly because no two tightening cycles begin with the same combination of inflation, company valuations, economic growth and financial conditions. It is useful nevertheless, not as a forecast, but because previous periods offer some perspective on the range of outcomes that can follow when monetary policy continues to tighten while markets are under pressure.
The first useful comparison is in 2018. The S&P 500 peaked on 20 September of that year but had fallen sharply by the time the Fed raised rates on 19 December, when the FOMC signalled further rate hikes for 2019. A sell-off deepened over the following days, leaving the index 19.4% below its peak by Christmas Eve, before Jerome Powell told an audience in Atlanta on 4 January 2019 that the Fed would be patient. The S&P 500 rose 3.4% that day and, by the end of the year, the FOMC had, in fact, cut rates three times. An important difference is that inflation was then running close to the Fed's target, giving it room to respond to slowing global growth and deteriorating financial conditions. Inflation today, however, leaves considerably less scope for the Fed to pause even if equity markets are weaker.
The second comparison is 1994, when Alan Greenspan’s Fed doubled the federal funds rate from 3% to 6% in a little over a year. Equities fell by more than 9% between February and April and finished 1994 down 1.5%, yet the economy slowed without contracting and the S&P 500 rallied 34.1% the following year. The circumstances, again, were different, with inflation of around 3%, a lower starting policy rate and an equity market trading on a trailing price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of roughly 19, but the period remains a useful reminder that a difficult tightening cycle does not necessarily translate into a prolonged equity bear market or recession.
The third comparison was between 1999 and 2000, when the Fed tightened into an equity market carrying much higher valuations, particularly in technology. The S&P 500 was trading on a trailing P/E of around 33 when the first rate hike took effect at the end of June 1999 and over the period that followed the NASDAQ Composite lost approximately 78% while the S&P 500 eventually surrendered almost half its value. It would be too simplistic to attribute those losses to higher interest rates alone: tighter monetary conditions increased the cost of capital, while weakening investor appetite and a contraction in equity and venture-capital funding exposed valuations and business models that were already vulnerable.
Looking at these periods is useful precisely because their outcomes were so different. The same broad policy action and higher interest rates produced very different market and economic results depending on the conditions that surrounded them, which is why attempting to identify today's equivalent from history is unlikely to be particularly useful. The more relevant question is whether higher rates are beginning to expose vulnerabilities in the current system, and whether those vulnerabilities will remain contained.
Understanding the dynamics in play
This makes the credit channel worth watching as the scale of investment associated with artificial intelligence (AI) has increased rapidly and some businesses involved in that build-out are growing faster than their balance sheets and credit profiles would ordinarily support. With the 10-year US Treasury yield trading around 5%, funding that expansion is materially more expensive than it was when capital was readily available at very low rates. That does not imply that investment in the sector is unsustainable, but it does mean the distinction between businesses able to fund growth from strong balance sheets and cash flows, and those dependent on continued access to external capital, becomes more important.
On a Treasury level, the Fed is unlikely to change course because equity prices alone have fallen, particularly while inflation remains above target, but its position would become more complicated if tighter financial conditions began feeding materially into credit availability, investment or employment. Those are therefore likely to be more useful indicators of where the monetary cycle is heading than the level of the equity market itself.
For investors, there is another side to the current environment. A 10-year US Treasury yield around levels not seen for many years provides an opportunity to earn meaningful income from high-quality dollar assets, while weaker equity markets can create opportunities when declines in share prices become broader than changes in the underlying prospects of individual businesses would justify. The experience of 1994 is relevant here, not because we should expect it to repeat, but because equities began recovering before the final rate increase, illustrating the difficulty of waiting for monetary policy or economic conditions to provide an obvious signal that it is safe to invest again.
For businesses, changing interest-rate and currency differentials also continue to create both risks and opportunities. Exporters and companies with dollar revenues may benefit from a firmer US currency, while importers in higher-yielding currencies may find that changes in the interest-rate differential with the US affect the cost of extending forward cover. As with investment markets, the objective should be to use periods of favourable pricing rather than attempt to predict the exact turning point in currencies or interest rates.
Getting context, but not a roadmap
The past therefore gives us useful context, but not a roadmap. Previous tightening cycles range from relatively orderly adjustments to periods of considerable market stress, and there is little value in assuming that the current cycle must ultimately resemble any one of them. What they do show is that markets tend to move before the economic or policy outlook becomes clear, and that the eventual outcome depends as much on underlying valuations, balance sheets and credit conditions as it does on the direction of interest rates themselves.
With a December rate hike largely priced in, the more important question is not simply whether the Fed raises rates again, but what conditions it will need before it stops. Inflation, credit conditions and employment will provide that answer over time. Until then, the appropriate response is not to try to predict which historical episode comes next, but to remain disciplined about valuation, diversified across sources of return and prepared to use opportunities as they emerge.
This week
Turning to the week’s markets
How bonds, equities, commodities and currencies moved over the week.
The week’s key themes
- Treasuries eased to around 5.03%, roughly 13 basis points lower on the week
- A sixth straight day of losses on Wall Street
- Gold has crashed to a 52-week low near $3,552/ounce
- The rand sits at a fresh 52-week low beyond R17.54/$, down around 3.6% on the week
Bonds
US Treasuries have been the quiet beneficiary of the equity sell-off. The 10-year benchmark sits near 5.09%, and about 13 basis points down on the week from 5.16%, as safe-haven demand drew money into longer-term assets even as the Fed stays firmly hawkish. Markets now price in a December rate increase at around 90% after a hot October US inflation print.
German Bunds have traded in the other direction, the 10-year edging up around two basis points to 3.41% and little changed on the week. Rising expectations that the European Central Bank (ECB) has further tightening to deliver, with forward markets having lifted the implied deposit-rate path, are offsetting the safe-haven appeal that would normally accompany an equity rout, leaving Bunds caught between the two forces.
United Kingdom (UK) gilts remain the highest-yielding major, the 10-year near 5.32% and a shade firmer on both Thursday and the week. With the Bank of England (BoE) having hiked rates recently and a roughly four-in-five chance of another move in December on the back of still-sticky inflation, gilts are drawing little of the safe-haven support flowing into Treasuries.
South African bonds were a relative bright spot. The 10-year rallied some eight basis points on Thursday to around 8.78%, leaving it only modestly higher on the week, after the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) held the repo rate at 7.25% at the final Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) meeting of the year, a hawkish hold, with three of seven MPC members pushing for a 25-basis-point hike and the SARB reaffirming its 3% inflation target after October CPI jumped to 5.2% from 4.5%.
Equities
Wall Street closed lower for a sixth consecutive session on Thursday. The S&P 500 shed 2.02% to 7,175.89, now down around 5.1% on the week; the NASDAQ 100 fell 2.21% to 26,517.05 and the NASDAQ Composite 2.25% to its lowest level since April, the broad NASDAQ off roughly 5% over the week; the Dow dropped 2.19% to 49,097, down a steeper 6.2%, and the Dow Jones Composite lost 1.84% to 15,736.6. Volatility spiked, with the VIX volatility index jumping some 16% toward 28. The move was a broad risk-off unwind led by AI and semiconductor names: Nvidia fell for a sixth straight session despite an upbeat forecast, AMD slid sharply on a short-seller disclosure, and cloud-infrastructure names were hit hard, with Palo Alto Networks the rare gainer on a raised outlook. Tellingly, the week's record-breaking Anthropic listing popped on debut but failed to revive sentiment.
That weakness carried into Asia this morning, where chip-heavy markets are bearing the brunt of cautious sentiment. The KOSPI is down 4.50% at 4,906, around 7% lower on the week; the Nikkei 225 has fallen 4.41% to 56,820, similarly off about 7% on the week and roughly 12% over four weeks; and the MSCI AC Asia Pacific index is down 3.05%. The AI-led de-rating is hitting the region's technology and semiconductor exporters hardest.
European markets were more resilient but still lower. The Euro Stoxx 50 fell 0.97% to around 6,184 on Thursday and is down on the week, dragged down by Wall Street but cushioned by its lighter technology weighting.
The UK’s FTSE 100 slipped 0.93% to roughly 10,453 and is likewise lower on the week; its defensive and commodity tilt offers some shelter, though the miners are exposed to the sharp fall in metal prices.
The local FTSE/JSE All Share Index closed 0.33% lower at 106,216, a fresh 52-week low. Gold miners and platinum-group names were the clear drag as bullion hit a 52-week low and the platinum group metals (PGM) complex fell further. With Asia down 3% to 4% and metals soft, the local market opened lower this morning, resources leading the downside; we are watching rand-hedge industrials to provide some offset, but the bias is clearly risk-off.
Commodities
Gold has fallen hard with spot gold at $3,552/ounce, down 2.02% overnight to a fresh 52-week low and extending a steep multi-week decline from above $3,900 only a week ago. A dollar near its highest level since early 2025, a near-certain December Fed hike and the higher-for-longer real-rates narrative that this implies have gutted the case for a non-yielding asset, and the January 2026 record price of near $5,600 now feels a world away.
Brent crude is subdued this morning, with the front-month pricing sitting at around $92.53/barrel and the spot contract near $90.35/barrel, keeping it broadly flat overnight and heading for a third straight weekly decline. Ample supply and a soft demand outlook, compounded by dollar strength, continue to cap the complex.
PGMs have been among the hardest hit asset classes. Platinum trades near $1,347/ounce, down about 1% on the session and close to 18% over the past month, with palladium off around 4% on Thursday and some 17% on the month. A strong dollar and rising real rates are driving the metals’ rout.
Currencies
The US Dollar Index sits near 103.9, broadly flat overnight but firm and close to its highest level since early 2025, up modestly on the week. A hawkish Fed and risk-off flows have made the dollar the epicentre of this week's cross-asset moves.
The euro is trading just under $1.10/€, soft and near its weekly lows, down roughly half a percent on the week. Rising expectations of further ECB tightening have not been enough to offset broad dollar strength, leaving the euro on the back foot.
Sterling is near $1.308/£, the weakest of the majors this week with a fall of about 1%, as UK growth and fiscal concerns weigh despite the BoE’s hawkish lean.
The rand sits at a fresh 52-week low, trading at R17.54/$, R19.23/€ and R22.95/£. It is around 0.3% weaker across the board overnight and some 3.6% softer against the dollar on the week. Global emerging market risk aversion, a surging dollar and a collapsing PGM complex are dominating. For corporates carrying foreign exchange risk, the break beyond R17.50/$ is a dollar-and-risk story, so the key to relief lies in a stabilisation of global sentiment rather than anything on the local front.